Despite the news (false, apparently) that he's not allowing ABC to use his "thumbs-up/thumbs-down" designation, Roger Ebert's reviews have been published with a series of stars lately. This story (with a really, well...sad picture of Roger) outlines the battle over the catch-phrase that launched a thousand stinkers.
To that end, I'd love to open up a discussion on how we should assign value to a film.
Stars are so '80s.
Popcorn tubs are lame.
Tomatoes are so '90s.
The thumbs up and down thing is way too general to offer any real advice. And I don't want to get sued.
So we can draft our own scale. Words are fine, but again they're pretty vague (bad, poor, good, excellent). Blah (picture curmedgeon shaking fist)!
A numerical scale(1-4; 1-5?) is fine, but we need to come up with an appropriate unit of measurement.
It would have to be something that can be applied to both good and bad films, though. Saying The Godfather earned five Brittany Crotch Shots is a far cry from awarding one BCS to Showgirls.
See what I mean?
I'm also cool with the partial designation. I mean, Brittany's Crossroads probably gets a BCS and a 1/2 (I'm guessing--haven't seen it).
So let me know what you think in the comments section. I'll ponder the subject over the weekend and hopefully we'll have some suggestions to discuss.
In the meantime, I hope that Michael Clayton earns at least three Kool-Aid attacks .
Welcome to the journal of writer Daniel Powell. Movies, books, and the occasional discussion of life and family...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
February Reviews: Gray Mountain, John Grisham
I enjoy John Grisham's books very much and I usually knock out a couple per year. I have read three so far in 2024, and his writing is...
-
One of the serendipitous outcomes of the 2020 stay-at-home orders (depending on your movie-going habits, of course) was a flood of excellent...
-
It doesn't get much more depressing than this story . Many years ago (like three or four) it would have been unheard of for kids this yo...
-
Aaron Polson is a talented writer who I think you can expect big things from in the coming years. A quick stop by his website offers links ...
No comments:
Post a Comment